Honestly, Corduroy was hard to find. Obfuscated by construction on one side and an abandoned building on the other, we passed it twice while our heads were on a swivel. Once we entered, we were glad we found it. Corduroy possesses a chic, modern interior accented by crisp, clean geometric lines. The place has a very well structured feel to it.
Upon arriving, drinks were ordered. I, the Sazerac; Huyen, the Lemongrass Cocktail. After an unfortunate incident with a floating fruit fly in my glass, the freshly re-prepared libation hit the spot. Their Sazerac captured that essential balance of sweetness/bitterness with a pleasantly subdued anise undertone. Excellent. The same cannot be said of their Lemongrass Cocktail. While it wasn’t bad, it wasn’t outstanding either. It was just good. Which is good. Sweet, straightforward, and simple; but we wished it had more lemongrass flavor.
The Noriko’s Shiso Salad was a pleasant enough experiment with raw bonito and shiso. There’s a fine line in my book of something “tasting like the sea” and tasting fishy so one could go either way with this one. This dish fell on the fishy side for me. The other appetizer was a cold tuna tartar floated on a warm sea of tomato jelly essence. The temperature contrast was happily surprising as well as the unusual flavor combination. The slight added texture of the occasional crunch of sea salt was appreciated.
The softshell crab entree arrived with fanfare as two enormous softshell crabs dominated the plate. While good and tasty, Huyen felt they were somehow lacking contrast. When you come to a fancy place like Corduroy, you’re usually expecting some kind of twist or uniqueness injected into your experience in each plate. We gave the softshells a grade of B. My entree was the wagyu beef strip steak. The cut of beef Corduroy chose didn’t do the wagyu heritage justice as the tenderness was lost while the flavor of all that marbling was smothered under a rich sauce. Now to be fair, it was a wonderful, tasty, good and salty/sweet sauce, and I enjoyed every bite. It’s nice to find a chef who isn’t afraid of salt. Oh, and just because you serve a great cut of steak doesn’t mean you get to skimp by with unremarkable sides like green beans and mashed potatoes. Yawn.
Dessert was a peach tarte tatin with a peach “creamsicle”. Outstanding. I have no idea how they created this throwback to the infamous orange creamsicle, but it’s worth going back just to have it again.
All dishes were plated cleanly and with an artistic eye.
Service was slow at times; but overall professional, courteous, and confident.
We’d go back.
